Chapter 118: A Bold Idea
"Aren't you just swindling him?"
As soon as Old Man Chen left, Grandmother, who had been holding back, could no longer contain herself and began to lecture Wu Ning.
"Twenty percent is twenty percent; why throw in those labor costs as well? Once he finds out later, won't he secretly resent you? You're making money for him, yet he won't even appreciate the favor. Why bother?"
"That's a different matter," Wu Ning said, waving his hand. "If I give him more now, he'll just think it's his due, or perhaps even believe we're the ones taking advantage of him. He wouldn't appreciate it at all. Besides, business is business. The ugly truths must be stated upfront, and the terms must be set in advance. If he’s unhappy in the future, I can always take back those labor costs, and he’ll surely be satisfied then. But if I give him twenty percent of the net profit now and he’s still unhappy later, what else could I possibly offer him?"
"Hmm." Grandmother mused, "That does make some sense."
She looked up and saw Qin Miaoniang standing nearby. "Girl, you're a business person too. Do you think Old Nine is doing the right thing?"
"Yes!" Qin Miaoniang nodded vigorously, helping Grandmother sit down. "It’s not that Brother Ning is being unrighteous; that’s just how the business world works."
"Hmph," Grandmother pouted. "Whatever he says, you always agree!" She turned back to Wu Ning. "But why can't you give him a bit more? Twenty percent of the stake is a good gain from Old Man Chen, but considering the high margins we have, I feel it’s a bit stingy."
"It’s not stingy," Wu Ning urged. "Any more, and he’ll start having other thoughts."
It was much like the listed companies of the future: if you are a small shareholder with only a sliver of equity, you certainly wouldn't dream of becoming the chairman and controlling the enterprise. But if you were a major shareholder with enough influence to dictate the company's direction, you would surely never be satisfied with just being a follower.
Therefore, twenty percent was the absolute limit. Wu Ning wouldn't give a cent more.
At this moment, Wu Laojiu began to calculate in his heart: Just yesterday, he was complaining that fifty strings of cash in half a year was too little, and today, business had come knocking. Currently, the seven kilns at Xiashan’ao had a production capacity of over 300,000 catties of charcoal over the winter. But if you added the dozen or so kilns at Chen Family Village, the situation would be entirely different. If he renovated the kilns at Chen Family Village, the winter output would be at least double that of Xiashan’ao. Combined, that would be a million catties!
One had to realize, the entire city of Fangzhou only consumed about that much charcoal in a winter.
Next, what Wu Ning had to think about was how to make all of Fangzhou use his Black Bamboo Charcoal and completely monopolize the market. This was a completely different scale from just relying on the few kilns at Xiashan’ao. If conditions permitted, he could even turn Fangzhou Black Bamboo Charcoal into a brand, radiating out to the neighboring Xiangzhou in the east, Sichuan to the south, and Chang’an and Luoyang to the northwest.
Thinking of this, Wu Ning raised an eyebrow and looked at Qin Miaoniang with a grin.
"Do you think Sun Hongde might grant a favor and waive the transit tax for shipments heading south to Bashu?"
"Huh?" Qin Miaoniang was startled. "Transit tax to the south? Isn't there no tax on the southern imperial roads?"
"Heh heh," Wu Ning gave a sly smile. "There will be in the future."
...
The transit tax Wu Ning spoke of sounded cryptic to outsiders, but to a citizen of the Tang Dynasty, it was immediately understood. It involved the Tang tax system and one of the two most important trade routes of the empire.
The Tang commercial tax was implemented through a two-tax system: "residency tax" and "transit tax."
The residency tax was the daily levy on fixed merchants in the markets: "Those who reside and trade in the markets pay the residency tax, thirty per thousand." In other words, a three percent sales tax based on the value of the goods sold.
The transit tax was a road toll. Government offices usually set up stations on the imperial roads, also based on the value of the goods in circulation: "Those who carry goods pay the transit tax, twenty per thousand," which was two percent.
Of course, there were "smugglers" who avoided the imperial roads to transport goods privately, but the imperial court was no pushover and guarded against this. If caught, "Those who trade extensively without using the official roads shall be punished. Those who have official duties pay one-tenth, known as the 'extraction tax'." This was actually quite humane; they didn't confiscate everything, but a high tax rate of ten percent was imposed.
If you chose to use the imperial road but hid the value of your goods, that wouldn't work either. "Those who dare to conceal goods and are caught by the authorities shall forfeit one-third of them, with half of that going to the informant."
In other words, if you concealed a certain amount, one-third would go to the government, and half of that would be rewarded to the person who reported it.
Furthermore, the Tang Dynasty did not implement a state monopoly on salt, meaning the management of salt was left to the private sector. Thus, the problem of salt smuggling, which plagued other dynasties, did not exist in the Tang. Because commercial taxes were low, few people took the risk of breaking the law to smuggle. Everyone was law-abiding, using the imperial roads and paying the transit tax.
...
As for the two most important trade routes of the Tang, one was the Grand Canal connecting the Yellow River and the Yangtze River, a waterway running from south to north. Emperor Yang of Sui might have been temperamental and indifferent to the suffering of the people when he built this canal, but it ended up benefiting the Li family.
Whether it was transporting grain from the south to the north or shipping exotic goods from abroad directly to the capital, the impact of this waterway on the Tang was monumental.
The other was the land route starting from Chang’an in the north and reaching Yizhou in the south, connecting the Central Plains with Bashu. The Sichuan Basin had always been a vital source of supplies in every dynasty. In the Tang, the Bashu region reached its peak; whether it was salt, tea, hemp paper, grain, rice wine, or Shu silk, everything was among the most sought-after goods of the era.
Therefore, this trade route from Chang’an southwards through Fangzhou and into Shu was second only to the Grand Canal. It helped cement the reputation that "the wealthiest in the world is Yangzhou, followed by Yizhou."
But if this was the second-largest land trade route in the world, why did Qin Miaoniang say no tax had been paid on it?
This was because the route was primarily used for Bashu to supply the heartland of the Central Plains—transporting goods from Yizhou to the Central Plains. Merchants heading north naturally had to pay the transit tax, but after delivering their goods to Chang’an, most merchant caravans returned empty.
Because compared to the abundance of Bashu, which lacked nothing, the Central Plains had nothing worth trading back. Even if there were goods, the taxes collected at various stations along the way would cause the prices to soar by the time they reached Shu, leaving no profit.
What Wu Ning was contemplating now was this: if the Shu merchants who returned empty-handed from Chang’an could fill their carts with Black Bamboo Charcoal in Fangzhou, and if Sun Hongde could keep one eye closed and continue not to collect the southern transit tax...
Then, the cost of transportation would effectively be nil, which was enough to ensure the market competitiveness of Black Bamboo Charcoal in Bashu. The business opportunity here was immense. How much charcoal would it take to fill a massive Sichuan Basin? Even if he duped ten more charcoal factories the size of Chen Family Village, it wouldn't be enough, would it?
"What kind of devious scheme are you cooking up?"
Grandmother noticed Wu Ning's expression and, after hearing his thoughts, was so shocked she nearly fell to the ground. "You child, you really dare to think!"